Fireside Folio

Thanksgiving dinner from old cookbooks: 1796 to 1931

Roast turkey, cranberries and “pompkin” pie from the first American cookbook (1796), Fannie Farmer’s Thanksgiving menu, and a 1931 USDA radio dinner. Every recipe as first printed, free as a book for your Kindle or e-reader.

Get the free book →

Thanksgiving dinner has been cooked from American cookbooks for more than two hundred years. We gathered the feast from four public-domain sources into one small free book, Thanksgiving Dinner, Then and Now, with every recipe quoted exactly as it was printed, odd spellings and all, plus notes for modern cooks.

1796: the first American cookbook

Amelia Simmons’s American Cookery, printed in Hartford, Connecticut, was the first cookbook written by an American and published in the United States. Her turkey is stuffed with bread, suet, eggs, thyme and marjoram, roasted before an open fire, and served “with boiled onions and cramberry-sauce.” Her second pumpkin pie is close to the one we bake today:

Pompkin. No. 2. One quart of milk, 1 pint pompkin, 4 eggs, molasses, allspice and ginger in a crust, bake 1 hour.

The 1870s: a table remembered

A woman brought up in Providence remembered her childhood Thanksgivings: a turkey of 19 to 28 pounds at one end of the table, a chicken pie at the other, three kinds of pie, and her grandmother baking 40 pies in a brick oven big enough for a child to climb into.

1896: Fannie Farmer’s menu

The Boston Cooking-School Cook Book set out a ten-line Thanksgiving menu, from oyster soup and salted almonds through roast turkey with cranberry jelly to mince, apple and squash pie, ice cream, and café noir. The book includes her turkey, chestnut stuffing, gravy, cranberry jelly and squash pie, from the 1910 printing.

1931: “Thanksgiving Dinner, Then and Now”

During the Depression, a US Department of Agriculture radio talk suggested keeping the best of the old feast but lighter: a tomato cocktail, turkey “or other fowl,” spinach in cream, a grapefruit salad with cornbread sticks, and pumpkin pie, with goose, rabbit or ham if the pocketbook said so.

Read the original books

How it works

  1. Create a free account at firesidefolio.com.
  2. Connect your reMarkable once with the one-time code from my.remarkable.com — or your Kindle with its Send-to-Kindle address.
  3. Tap Send. On a reMarkable it arrives on your next sync, in its own folder; on a Kindle it arrives through Amazon within a few minutes.

Questions

Can I cook from these?

Yes, with care. The 1796 recipes give few quantities and assume an open fire, so treat them as a starting point. Fannie Farmer’s are measured and work much as written. Whatever the old books say, cook the turkey and any stuffing inside it to 165°F (74°C).

Is the book really free?

Yes. All three sources are in the public domain in the United States, and the book is free to read, send and share.

How do I get it on my Kindle?

Open the book on firesidefolio.com and tap send. With a free account and your Send-to-Kindle address connected, it arrives in your Kindle library in a minute or two. It works the same on Kobo, reMarkable, PocketBook and Boox.

Get the free book →

More guides

Fireside Folio is free and made by Trieflow LLC. It isn’t affiliated with reMarkable AS or Amazon. · Privacy · Terms · Contact